Frank Furter wrote:
> y_p_w wrote:
>
> > Frank Furter wrote:
> >
> > > Just curious, how big is this group?
> >
> > It was buried, but a size of about 20 was mentioned.
>
> Yes,
> Now I see it (as I read the posts for the third time). From the
> questions, it seems like bluskyz08 has not been to Half Dome or
> at least not in the summer.
> I would like to say this a gently as possible, but I think that
> there should be some re-thinking of the idea that just because
> something like taking a large group to Half Dome can be done,
> that it should be done.
Summer to Half Dome depends on the day of the week. Midweek isn't bad. I did it on a Thursday and frankly the crowds were manageable. I saw a group of at least 12 and they looked to be OK. It looked a bit more crowded from my telephoto shots from my Clouds Rest hike the next day, but not too bad. Later that trip I was waiting at the Roads End Permit Station at Kings Canyon chatting away with the permit officer (frankly he had nobody to talk to most of the day) and I noticed the photo of the crowded Half Dome cables with the caption "Be glad this isn't Yosemite". It was one of the typical summer weekend days at the cables, where there literally wasn't more than 3 feet between anyone and the backup to get on the cables was maybe 50+ people deep.
> By this discussion, are we facilitating the wrong use of this
> area? Any group of this size is likely to have a huge
> variation in abilities, be at increased risk of having members
> spread out over miles of the trail (thus extending the stay of
> everyone in the group), put extreme pressure on the toilet
> facilities, add to the crush of people at the bottom of the
> cables, etc. If the group does stay together, it will be like
> a pack train to the top of Half Dome with more noise and
> "human" impact. I argue that even 5 groups of 4 spread out
> over time have less impact than a large collection of
> individuals who would want to often stay together for meals or
> breaks.
It's already a pack-train to the top of Half Dome. It gets more manageable when groups carry radios.
In any case, Yosemite's day use group limit in wilderness areas is 35. Just stay on the trail and you're not considered going cross-country. I you need to "do your business" off trail, approach it in groups of 8 or less.
http://www.nps.gov/yose/planyourvisit/backpackinggroups.htmQuote
Large Groups
In order to preserve the natural and aesthetic value of the Yosemite Wilderness, groups of eight people or more should be aware of the following information.
Group Size Limits
Day hiking group size limit: 35
Overnight group size limit: 15
Cross-country use group size limit (day hiking or overnight): 8
> As remarkable as the trip to Half Dome is, I personally do not
> think it is a wise project for a large group given the physical
> challenge it presents, the condition of the trail, and the
> facilities in route.
I think it's manageable. Members of the group should probably temper their expectations, and not get disappointed if the plans don't work out (such as summer rain making the ascent up the cables dangerous).
I would also note that gloves are very helpful to help with grip and to protect the hands. I heard that the NPS started hauling out many of the gloves left behind in that hole carved at the base that were rotting away. I did it wearing two mismatching rubber-palmed cotton gloves that I pulled from the supply at the base of the cables; I figured they would work better than what I had. I brought a pair of leather work gloves, but determined that those rubber-palmed gloves would be better. The best known example is Atlas, but there are numerous similar gloves. They'll give excellent grip on the cables but breathe to an extent. I use one of these for shucking oysters.
[edit] - Had to correct some egregious proofreading errors.
Post Edited (03-18-09 10:33)