y_p_w wrote:
>
>
> Wow - I spent a total of $15 for "lodging" the last time I went
> backpacking in Yosemite. $5 for the wilderness permit
> reservation (I know it's more now) and $5 each night to stay in
> the Valley backpacker's campground.
>
> It's the ancillary stuff that cost me a small fortune though,
> like the backpack, the sleeping bag, camp stove/cookware, bear
> canister, etc. And the Tioga Road shuttle (to drop me off at
> the trailhead) was $14. I think I spent more than all that
> combined on one meal at the Mountain Room.
Thats exactly it. Think if you were to fly across country to a park you had never been to before.
Firstly, you cannot bring your own stoves or fuel. Those must be rented or purchased or borrowed. Flying with packs is generally a big hassle because they tend to loose stuff and must be checked. Delta now charges for EVERY checked bag.
Once you arrive, if you get wet, you have to pack wet and/dirty equipment back home, you have to spend a heck of a lot of time getting oriented and getting permits ( in Glacier NP, you have to sit through a 3O minute film on bears; carry a shovel; and camp only in designated camps, etc etc). It seems like for the first trip (especially if you are flying out) a person is well advised to purchase some luxury for the visit. Certainly the Valley is not all of Yosemite, but a person could find a lot to do for a first visit just in the Valley. I have been to Yos many times over the last 40 years and could put together easily a week just in the Valley again. On the first visit-- do the "tourist" stuff, ride the shuttle, go to visitor center, sit in on some of the ranger campfires. All that is great stuff.
The cure for a fallacious argument is a better argument, not the suppression of ideas.
-- Carl Sagan