Re: Yosemite judge's noose leads to tossed verdict

Now a hangman's noose is a symbol of racial hatred?

Good thing the guy didn't murder somebody. He'd have gotten off scot-free (whoops, is that racial???) thanks to politically-correct Judge Wanker...

---

Gary
Yosemite Photo Galleries: http://www.pbase.com/roberthouse/yo

Quote
Sierrafan
Now a hangman's noose is a symbol of racial hatred

That IS more than a bit of a stretch...a scary trend this might turn out to be.

b

The Fresno Bee link needs a login now. Here's one that's working:

http://www.mercurynews.com/breakingnews/ci_12149691

What puzzles me about this issue is that the noose was in the judge's chambers. This usually refers to the "backoffice" of the court that is outside the public view and often personalized by certain personal items like moose heads or golf trophies. It is hard to understand how something in chambers could be construed to influence a courtroom decision. If a judge has a hamburger in chambers, will he then not be able to provide justice to someone with a vegetarian lifestyle? I would have some sympathy if the noose was in the courtroom, but chambers seems a stretch.

---

The cure for a fallacious argument is a better argument, not the suppression of ideas.
-- Carl Sagan

Quote
Frank Furter
I would have some sympathy if the noose was in the courtroom, but chambers seems a stretch.

That's just what I was thinking. Shouldn't this mean all the convictions rendered must go as well?

The odd part is that if I picture a hangman's noose in use, there aren't any American Indians in it...the stereotype is wild west outlaws (cowboy-type) or maybe the famous photo of Lincoln's asassin being hanged. What has old Wanker been watching? (oh, did I misspell his name...never mind, it's a better fit anyway 8^).

The old movies, at least, would have led one to think, were I foolish enough to use Wanker's reasoning, that guns are a symbol of racial hatred, since they were used against the American Indians. Uh-oh, here comes Vince...8^)

---

Gary
Yosemite Photo Galleries: http://www.pbase.com/roberthouse/yo

Guess who wants Wunderlich's job!

Quote
Vince
Guess who wants Wunderlich's job!

490 Views for Vince's response?! You the man, VinceB)

(Grrrrrr)

QB

Quote
Bee

Quote
Vince
Guess who wants Wunderlich's job!

490 Views for Vince's response?! You the man, VinceB)

(Grrrrrr)

QB

470+ of those were Vince.

Quote
szalkowski

Quote
Bee

Quote
Vince
Guess who wants Wunderlich's job!

490 Views for Vince's response?! You the man, VinceB)

(Grrrrrr)

QB

470+ of those were Vince.

That was obvious.

Quote
eeek

Quote
szalkowski

Quote
Bee

Quote
Vince
Guess who wants Wunderlich's job!

490 Views for Vince's response?! You the man, VinceB)

(Grrrrrr)

QB

470+ of those were Vince.

That was obvious.

I would not have thought to do that.....

Diversity is way overrated

QB

Quote
Bee

Quote
eeek

Quote
szalkowski

Quote
Bee

Quote
Vince
Guess who wants Wunderlich's job!

490 Views for Vince's response?! You the man, VinceB)

(Grrrrrr)

QB

470+ of those were Vince.

That was obvious.

I would not have thought to do that.....

Diversity is way overrated

QB

You'd probably get bored pounding on the reload button too.

Quote
eeek

Quote
Bee

Quote
eeek

Quote
szalkowski

Quote
Bee

Quote
Vince
Guess who wants Wunderlich's job!

490 Views for Vince's response?! You the man, VinceB)

(Grrrrrr)

QB

470+ of those were Vince.

That was obvious.

I would not have thought to do that.....

Diversity is way overrated

QB

You'd probably get bored pounding on the reload button too.

Yes...how odd....(I am still scratching my head over this one)

QB

Quote
szalkowski

Quote
Bee

Quote
Vince
Guess who wants Wunderlich's job!

490 Views for Vince's response?! You the man, VinceB)

(Grrrrrr)

QB

470+ of those were Vince.

I love it when i get a joke

http://www.metnews.com/articles/2004/wund022604.htm

And so it goes.

Just from my perspective.

When I first heard that the Yosemite judge had a hangman's noose I thought it was kind of funny.

But then I imagined how I would feel if I were being judged by this man. Going to court, I would already be feeling quite intimidated and anxious.

If I then discovered that the judge had a hangman's noose, that would send a message to me. I would feel that he was quick to judge and tended to side with the prosecution. I would also feel that he enjoyed dominating over others and having them squirm under his authority. Whether those assumptions are true or not, I don't know. But that's how I would feel. And I'm white.

By the way, the article says the prosecution has the option to re-try the case (with a different judge).